This is the second part of Bullshido versus Karate Tradition. Building on my previous article, I will continue how to distinguish true martial skill from superficial or deceptive techniques.
Bullshido vs. Legitimate Tradition
Many modern critics call traditional karate bullshido simply because they see ritual, kata, or formal technique. That view ignores the deeper structure of traditional practice. Old-style karate uses kata to encode practical lessons. The training develops reflex, structure, and timing through repetition, not fantasy.
Each kata has a physical purpose that becomes clear through bunkai and partner work. When applied with proper understanding, these movements are as effective today as they were in the 19th century.
Why Traditionalists Push Back
Traditional teachers argue that not all value in martial arts can be measured by competitive fighting. Modern combat sports take place under rules that limit the range of techniques. Karate, as a self-defense system, addresses situations not found in sport – grabs, multiple attackers, or sudden ambushes. Kata and prearranged drills prepare the body and mind for these situations.
Traditionalists also emphasize that kata is not only about fighting. It develops coordination, breathing control, mental discipline, and body alignment. These qualities improve both combat skill and personal development. Calling that “bullshido” shows you don’t understand what the training is meant to do.
Cross-Training and the Search for Proof
Many traditional dojos today blend old methods with modern testing. Instructors include techniques from judo, jujutsu, or full-contact sparring to show that their kata principles work under pressure. This is not a rejection of tradition; it is a return to its roots. The early Okinawan teachers often trained in different systems, sharing methods with Chinese and local experts. In my opinion, if you study the kata carefully, you will see that throws, armlocks, and grappling are already part of it. The old masters had already incorporated all these aspects. The modern way of splitting techniques into styles like judo (throws and grappling) and karate (strikes, blocks, kicks) is just a way of categorizing them today.
The Role of Honesty in Rank and Lineage
A significant part of bullshido comes from false rank claims and invented lineages. Some individuals promote themselves to tenth dan, claiming to have inherited secret traditions. Authentic Okinawan karate avoids this problem by maintaining modest rank structures and clear transmission lines.
In Okinawa, many respected masters held fifth or sixth dan for life, focusing on skill rather than title. Teachers like Nagamine Shoshin, Mabuni Kenwa, and Miyagi Chojun defined rank by ability and teaching, not by certificates. This cultural humility is the best defense against the commercial inflation seen in many modern dojos.
When Kata Becomes Evidence, Not Decoration
A serious karateka can demonstrate the difference between true karate and bullshido through application. A simple kata motion – like the downward block and reverse punch – can be shown as an arm trap followed by a counter-strike. The proof lies in demonstration under resistance.
Instructors who can explain and apply every part of their kata have nothing to hide. Their art is functional, whether or not it resembles modern sport fighting. Instructors who avoid explanation or testing invite doubt and criticism. The art is validated by its effectiveness, not by reputation.
Old Lessons for a Modern Problem
The fight against bullshido is not new. Early Okinawan masters already warned against empty training. Itosu Anko wrote that karate should build character and strength through constant testing. Kenwa Mabuni stressed that every kata movement must be studied and understood. Gichin Funakoshi said that karate is “not for display but for life”.
These principles reject everything that bullshido represents. They call for constant study, correction, and honesty about skill level. A true dojo follows that path, whether it trains for combat or character.
Modern Examples of Anti-Bullshido Karate
Across the world, traditional dojos have reintroduced bunkai-based training and applied drills. Some use light protective gear to allow full-power execution of kata applications. Others train two-person versions of kata, in which the defender and attacker move in synchronization to study timing and rhythm.
This movement shows that traditional karate can
